All of this comes from the the wonderful folks at Skin Deep (EWG). Their research has completely changed the products that I’m purchasing for my family. We were spending tons of money on Mustella thinking it was the best (though they seem to be changing).
We are now using the list below. Some of them are not THE safest but brands like California Baby are easier to find than some of the other products.
Baby Shampoo/Wash
Baby Organic 2 in 1 Coconut Foam Coconut Shampoo & Body Wash (Rated Zero / Safest)
California Baby Calming Wash (Rated 2)
Wipes
Seventh Generation (Rated 1)
Sunscreen
California Baby (Rated 1)
Diaper Cream
California Baby Diaper Wash (Rated 0)
California Baby Diaper Cream (Rated 2)
*Eventually switching to MadeOn DiaperCream (Rated O)
Lotion for Mom/Dad
MadeOn Bars (Rated 1)
Bugspray
Badger BugBalm
HandSoap (Diluted in a foaming bottle)
Dr. Bronners
Hand Sanitizer
CleanWell
